Best Supporting Actor 1945: Results

5. John Dall in The Corn is Green- Dall gives a dull boring performance that fits his rather dull film.

4. J. Carrol Naish in A Medal for Benny- Naish is the best part of his film, and does give some emotional weight to his performance, but it is still is not anything that special.

3. Robert Mitchum in The Story of G.I. Joe- Mitchum gives a good performance that creates an effective realistic portrait of a soldier leading his troops.

2. Michael Chekhov in Spellbound-Michael Chekhov does not have too many scenes at his disposal but he makes the most of all of them giving an effective scene stealing performance.

1. James Dunn in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn- James Dunn easily gives the best supporting performance of the year. Dunn gives a wonderful emotionally powerful performance that perfectly finds both the charm and the tragedy of his character.

Best Supporting Actor 1945: Michael Chekhov in Spellbound

Michael Chekhov received his only Oscar nomination for portraying Dr. Alexander Brulov in Spellbound.

Spellbound is a lesser Alfred Hitchcock thriller about an amnesiac (Gregory Peck) who may or may not be a murderer who is being helped by a psychoanalyst Dr. Constance Peterson (Ingrid Bergman).

Michael Chekhov was best known as a theater actor, as well as his philosophies on acting, but he did have a few film roles one of them being this film which earned him an Oscar nomination. Spellbound is not a great Hitchcock film with a lacking lead, and a great deal of dialogue that probably should have been rewritten. Michael Chekhov's Dr. Brulov does not appear until the second half of the film after Bergman's character has gone on the run with Peck's while trying to decipher what has caused his amnesia.  She brings him to her former mentor Dr. Brulov's house to hide out, believing Brulov won't notice the troubled state of Peck.

Chekhov makes Dr. Brulov a big breath of fresh air for the film which was becoming stale on Bergman's and Peck's exchanges. Chekhov instantly brings some much needed life into the picture as the devoted, and opinionated psychoanalyst.Chekhov exudes a certain charm in the role, and flawlessly establishes Dr. Brulov's "credentials" seemingly without effort. Although it most certainly is true that he almost seems to be Freud in all but name Chekhov still manages to not just be some cheap imitation and is capable of portraying intelligence of Dr. Brulov quite well.

He brings a great deal of life in his part as the intelligent insightful Dr. Brulov who is both charming as well as brings a certain weight to his words that realizes the idea of psychoanalysis in a far more fulfilling fashion than the rest of the film was able to do. Chekhov gives an enjoyable turn that livens up the film when it is very much needed. In fact Chekhov effective depiction of Dr. Brulov actually made me far more interested in Brulov than the rest of the characters in the film. In fact what Chekhov does do in the role made me wish the film had actually been more about him.

This actually quite achievement in its own way by Chekhov since he really only has a few scenes, but every moment he does have are very well spent. Even though his character is limited just like his time his performance is always the best part of the scenes he is in as well as really the best part of the film. It is really a great example of a great actor being able to do something special with a role no matter how simple and limited might be as written. It is not completely unforgettable performance by any means like say Claude Rains in Notorious, but it is a true scene stealer.

Best Supporting Actor 1945

And the Nominees Were:

Michael Chekhov in Spellbound

J. Carrol Naish in A Medal for Benny

James Dunn in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn 

John Dall in The Corn is Green

Robert Mitchum in The Story of G.I. Joe